Re: Okuma MB-46VAE Z-axis ball screw backlash growing — how long can I keep running?
Reply 3 (by QualityMgr_Aerospace):
If you're doing any tolerance-critical work — aerospace, medical, automotive precision components — you really should put a go/no-go decision on this sooner rather than later because Z-axis backlash creep affects every operation involving plunge moves, drilling depth, peck cycles, and any tool path that reverses Z direction mid-feature. I've seen shops run with "compensated" ballscrew wear on Okuma vertical machining centers for months thinking parts were fine, then get a customer audit that pulls SPC data showing their Z-depth feature variation has been slowly trending out for weeks. Okuma's Thermal Friendly Concept on the MB-46VAE does a good job managing thermal growth but it cannot compensate for mechanical backlash, and the two error sources compound each other in a way that's hard to catch without real process monitoring data. Run a capability study on a Z-direction feature before you decide to defer the repair.